Sacramento Landlords: When Holding a Single-Family or Small Multifamily Rental Stops Making Sense

It's January! The holidays are behind us. The calendar has flipped to a new year...and this week I found myself having a familiar conversation: a Sacramento multifamily property owner called me and wanted to talk through "if it still makes sense for me to own this rental property". For this person, the short answer was NO. And perhaps at some point I will list this property. 

I hear this most often from owners of single-family rental homes, and owners of small multifamily properties like duplexes, triplexes, and fourplexes. These guys are not institutional investors. They’re what we refer to commonly as "mom and pop investors" -- meaning regular people who bought with a long-term plan in mind: retirement income, cash flow, or long-term wealth building. And let's face it, for a long time, that plan has worked well. 

But heading into 2026, perhaps the calculus has shifted. 

• Maybe they talked to their CPA and some of the tax advantages of owning rental investment property have run their course. Depreciation is usually part of this conversation. Many long-term rental owners are nearing full depreciation, meaning the tax advantages that once made ownership especially appealing are starting to fade. When those benefits diminish, it often prompts a closer look at whether continuing to hold still makes sense. 
• Maybe they are considering retiring and riding off into the sunset in their RV and owning rental property in Sacramento is not something they want the responsibility for. Some landlords begin to wonder whether keeping that equity locked inside a rental property is still the best use of their capital. For landlords approaching retirement there is often a shifting desire for liquidity and simplicity. Selling a rental property can provide funds to support retirement, reduce risk, and eliminate the day-to-day responsibilities that come with being a landlord. 
• Maybe they already live outside of the area and coordinating repairs and keeping up with tenant issues from a distance is too much to manage. Absentee owners, in particular, may decide it’s time to cash in, simplify their lives, and redeploy the proceeds toward other investments, lifestyle goals, or greater financial flexibility. 
• Maybe a tenant has stopped paying rent and they are faced with an expensive eviction, and just do not want to deal anymore. Or perhaps a tenant has provided notice to vacate, and it proves to be an opportune time to sell rather than re-rent the property. 
• Maybe they want to help their adult kids buy their first home, and selling the old rental property is the perfect vehicle for a tax deferred 1031 Exchange. A lot of my clients are considering how to help their adult kids become homeowners and maybe give them the inheritance a little early. 
• Maybe expenses like insurance premiums are increasing, or there are some anticipated large repair expenses looming due to some deferred maintenance. A new roof, a new HVAC, a new sewer line, dryrot or termites...these can be big ticket items if a housing provider does not have liquid reserves set aside. 
• Maybe they aren't excited with the direction the California legislature is going with tenant protections and the ever-evolving regulatory landscape, and they are over it. In the last few years, California has enacted AB1482 rent caps and just cause eviction, has limited the amount a landlord can charge as a rental deposit, and has now required landlords to provide refrigerators and stoves as a condition of habitability. 
• Maybe they never intended to be a landlord in the first place! They inherited the property, or maybe couldn't get the price they wanted when they moved out of the property and decided to rent it out. 

You get the idea. 

Every year I have these conversations with property owners looking to go out of the rental business. That naturally leads to questions about opportunity cost. What am I currently not doing that I could be doing if the equity in this property were liquid, or if I weren't tied down? In the Sacramento market, single-family rentals and 2–4 unit properties continue to attract strong buyer interest. Buyers include owner-occupants planning to live in one unit and rent the others, as well as long-term investors looking for stable, well-located assets. Properties with solid fundamentals remain in demand. 

Reach out and I am happy to talk it through with you, analyze your income and expenses, the rental market and scenario, and to give you a sense of what your property might be worth.